A Novel by C. J. Toller
Forgiveness is her favorite weapon.
Rebecca Hale always takes off her cross before she gets into the truck.
Afterward she puts it back on, fixes her lipstick in his mirror, and drives to lunch with her daughter.
She is the most loved woman in Charleston: a widow with burn-scarred palms, the founder of a shelter for battered women, a voice a million listeners trust.
Her husband, Thomas, has found her red notebook: four powerful men, four sums of money, four small crosses.
And Rebecca knows.
So she forgives him. Then her church starts praying for his jealousy.
His prison is built of prayer meetings, casseroles and immigration forms. One word from her, afraid, and all of Charleston will see a monster in him.
The last man in her life, she says, just left one night.
His mother still puts up flyers.
Available on Amazon. Free to read with Kindle Unlimited.

At a glance
- Author
- C. J. Toller (pen name)
- Publisher
- TollerBooks, 2026
- Genre
- Psychological thriller, domestic noir, Southern gothic
- Setting
- Charleston, South Carolina
- Formats
- Kindle $5.99 · Paperback $17.99 · Free with Kindle Unlimited
- Content notes
- See the FAQ
Official teaser
Watch the teaser
She keeps a little book. Some of you are in it.
Images, motion, voice and music created with AI.
Get the book → (opens Amazon in a new tab)LADY BY DAY · THIEF BY NIGHT
A fiction podcast from the novel
Midnight Bread
Every Monday, Rebecca Hale records a devotional for a million listeners. Now you can hear her too.
Enter Midnight Bread
A Christian Psychopath Book Club
The Red Notebook
Two hosts, one novel, one question: is Rebecca Hale a saint or a predator?
Enter the book clubWhy this title
A portrait of one woman who wears faith as a costume
This novel does not judge believers, and it diagnoses no one real. Rebecca Hale is a fictional character, and the people she deceives are sincere Christians. Their sincerity is what makes her possible.
The book opens with a verse that says it better than any title could:
“And no marvel; for Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light”
It was written so that sincere people learn to recognize the costume.
The library
Understanding the Patterns
Clear, sourced articles on spiritual abuse, manipulation and coercive control. Information, not counseling.
Faith as a weapon
When Forgiveness Becomes a Weapon
How a sacred duty can become pressure to stay silent.
Read article: When Forgiveness Becomes a WeaponRecognizing the signs
The Female Narcissist in the Church
The patterns people miss when the charming one is a woman.
Read article: The Female Narcissist in the ChurchThe basics
What Is Spiritual Abuse?
Definitions, signs and what the research says.
Read article: What Is Spiritual Abuse?
Newsletter